Thursday, April 29, 2010

The Opera: Why I Didn't Like Don Giovanni

Last night was the final production for the 2009/2010 Calgary Opera season. It ended with a bang- errrr... explosion with the Mozart opera Don Giovanni. I didn't like it. At all. First of all, it had been modernized. Originally, I had been excited about this fact. Written in the late 1700's the production company transported the opera to take place in today's world. Instead of sets and costumes conducive to the period it was originally written the character were now prancing around in power suits, True Religions and cell phones. Instead of being drunk on wine in his final moments of life, Don Giovanni was high on Cocaine and pills. All of this took place in an office building during a merger (I'm not making any of this up). Don Giovanni kept a list of his thousands (and I mean thousands) of conquests in a USB stick which hung around his "assistants" neck. I'm pretty sure it was all put into a spreadsheet using Excel.

I found the "today-ness" of the show to be distracting, within the first 10 minutes of the opera someone had been murdered. In today's world someone would have called 911 on their cell phone however in the opera  the characters ran around trying to play Sherlock Holmes on their own. Of course that would have been natural for the 18th Century but for the 21st? Doesn't fit and just looks silly.  I am pretty sure Mozart rolled over in his grave a few million times at the slaughter that had taken place in this otherwise decent enough opera. It's sad. This ridiculous aspects of this show totally distracted for the true talent of the performers.

The first scene (which was 80 minutes long) involved a fair bit of action- in all senses of the word. By then end of it though, I was falling asleep. There was a lack of melody that often rings through delicate and cheerful with most of Mozart operas. The costumes of business attire and janitor jumpsuits were dull on the eyes and by the time it was over I thought there wasn't anymore that could be done.

*enter 20 minute intermission- most of that spent standing in line for the ladies room*

The second scene (which was just over 60 minutes long) held more of the pretty arias but still I found that I was falling asleep. It wasn't until Don was visited by a "ghost" in the bathroom (seriously) that things got kind of strange. The next thing I remember is Don Giovanni standing in a dumpster in a back alley eating McDonald's with his assistant, which then exploded. That scared the living daylights out of me- by this point I was counting the lights in the ceiling of the auditorium and doing simple math in my head.

Then it was done. There was a mad dash to the door and my dad and I were out of there. Being a true opera lover he had very similar if not more negative feeling about this version of Don Giovanni. I think something more classic would have been a better choice. In the past I have seen operas that had been made with more of a contemporary eye and they have been successful. Opera, to me, is about romance. Tragedy.. heavy emotions that linger in the air like Chanel No. 5. This was nothing of the sort, it felt cheap, dirty and just riddled with STD's. It was more of an opera about Tiger Woods then about a romantic legend and without a doubt, I would suggest that Don Giovanni make an appearance on the next season of Celebrity Rehab.

and that is how I feel about that.

2 comments:

Ian said...

Like you, I tend to prefer more traditional performances of Mozart. I was lucky enough to see Don Giovanni at the Estates Theater in Prague, where Mozart conducted its premiere in 1797, after composing the overture the night before.

amourissima said...

That was lucky of you, what a nostalgic atmosphere to see such an opera. I'm sure it enriched the experience ten fold.